Saturday, November 14, 2026

Learning and the Brain - Austin - Raw Notes for Saturday

Note: These are raw notes, taken in real time during the presentation. They have not been edited. I also have a tendency to add my own thoughts as I take notes. While I try to make note of that, I sometimes don't know the difference. If you find something offensive, don't blame the speaker because it might be my thoughts and not theirs.

Keynote I: Just Do This: Create a More Engaging and Inspiring School Culture by Steven A. Bollar, MA

His book is called Stand Tall, which is apt. He appears to be about 6'8". He just said it; he is is 6'7".

He started 8th grade 5'8" and ended it at 6'2" and he did not embrace becoming a tall person. He had anxiety attacks before bed. He was in constant pain and had debilitating chest pains. He had to wear a heart monitor (which looks like a purse). He started to slouch to try and blend in. (Personal note: I tried that, and it doesn't work. It doesn't make you look shorter. It makes you look like a sloppy tall person.) His friend punched him in the back and told him to stop trying to be a small person and stand tall.

Leaders are not supposed to blend in.

Communication - Void negative self talk. Your inner dialogue will convince you of things that are not true if you let it. what do you say to yourself when you get to work? What do you say to your self before the students enter or after they leave? Is it purposeful and positive? Catch yourself being negative, challenge it, and then change it to something more true and productive.

Respect and values are the anchor for climate and culture.

Climate is the emotional state people feel when they enter a space. It is fluid compared to values. Climate fluctuates from day to day. Culture is the collection of traditions and routines. 

  • Operational culture - the systemic process and practices that are designed to enforce the organizational values.
  • Behavior Culture - expected actions and what is tolerated by members of the organization
Fun things give you some climate spikes, but they don't sustain it over time. Aligning what you respect and value with your operational and behavior culture will keep the climate more consistent. 

Replace "They should know" with "Have we made it clear?"

Recognition - Do you recognize staff and students for living up to the things you respect and value. 

Recognition is not a prize, a trophy, or a sticker. It is opening your mouth and saying something nice. Notice when they have aligned with the organizational values and say something to acknowledge it.

There is a time and a place for Daytime DJ Voice (hyper) and Nighttime DJ Voice (quiet and smooth). Use Daytime DJ voice for positives and acknowledgments and Nighttime DJ Voice for negatives. 

Consequences lead to compliance. Recognition leads to commitment. Compliance is not bad, but it leads to following a minimum standard. Commitment leads to a feeling of loyalty to the organization that makes them motivated to give the maximum. If you obtain commitment, compliance will take care of itself.



Integrity - A set of beliefs , values, and actions that others can depend on.

Maintaining integrity

  • Keep your promises
  • Speak out for what you believe in
  • Err on the side of fairness
  • Do what you say you are going to do

Share what is original to you with others.


Keynote II: The Human Check: Why Short Oral Vivas Are the Secret Engine of True Mastery by Jonathan H. Bergmann, MA

Book Flip Your Classroom and 12 others, article "AI Will Stupefy our Students Unless We Do These Six Things"

Personal note: I didn't recognize his name, but when I saw him I realized that I have used his flipping the classroom videos before. 

Was doing oral assessments with his students - They got the right answer, but they didn't understand it. He would have missed it if he had only been reading answers on paper.

His AI Experience:

His principal asked him to explore AI because "it seems like it is going to be a big deal." He looked at it and thought it would make everything better. He started using it early. Students hated it. He got the worst reviews of his life. 

One of his students had difficulty with a problem and immediately went to AI to solve it. He realized if she had sat with it for 3 more minutes, she would have gotten it. But she outsourced it to AI. Homework scores were great, and test scores were terrible. 

Sal Kahn wrote a book about how AI was going to be the wave of the future. He has recently come out to say he was wrong about its benefits.

AI was built for the boardroom, not the classroom. It's built for efficiency, but the inefficiency of the classroom is a feature, not a bug. Students are meant to engage in productive struggle. AI prevents that by reducing the neural friction. 

It's one thing when an expert uses it because they already have a mental model, and it extends their thinking. When a novice uses it, they are still building mental models, and I skips the work that would help them build that muscle. According to Hattie's research, if you give an expert an AI, it can improve their thinking by 2 to 5 times. If you give it to a novice, it will reduce their thinking. 

Software developers lost their ability to debug systems by 17% when they became accustomed to using AI to build the systems. 

Viva = oral assessments

You can't send home cognitively complex work anymore. It has to be done in class. 

He and a team of people created a "mastery flip" approach to his classes. He was already making videos for kids to watch at home, so having them do that home is fine, even if they use AI. But he returned to his analog roots DURING class. Textbooks and human feedback ONLY during the in class portion. His assessments are now oral because he can absorb non-verbal feedback along with the words they are saying.

Students prepare for the Viva by rehearsing with an AI verbally, refining it by talking through errors, and then coming in to talk to the teacher.

Vivas help with thinking, but the larger benefit is that it makes your classroom more human.

This is the oldest tool in teaching: A conversation

Personal note: Everyone knows how I feel about the existence of AI. This is the first time I have heard someone talk about a model I might be willing to use if I were still in the classroom. It isn't naive about their using AI at home, but it keeps it out of the actual classroom so that the thinking is analog and the feedback is human.

Concurrent Session D: Part 1 The Science of Expectancy Value Theory by Nistha Dube

Note: I was 15 minutes late to this one because I was speaking to some people at my exhibit table and then to Jon Bergmann

Strengths Based Learning - Using students strengths to build self-efficacy to help them recognize that they can overcome academic challenges. Helps them have a more accurate perception of their own competency.

What does an Autonomy-oriented environment increase? Students have a higher perception of their efficacy as opposed to a control-oriented environment. (Personal note: This doesn't mean a free for all where kids do whatever they want. The teacher decides the boundaries, but they allow autonomy within those boundaries.)

Since deficit mindset focuses more on what is wrong with students and what they are missing, teachers may miss out on the opportunity to acknowledge and leverage students' strength and resources.

Write and share model - Ask students to write about their experiences - "Give three examples of what you learned"- will refocus students on tasks.

Helping students think through purpose with this diagram can be helpful.




Concurrent Session D: Part 2 - Engaging Student Values, Voices, Choice in Learning Experiences by Alexa Sorden

The shift from participation to ownership: Students attaching the learning to their values makes them more motivated to connect. If they have voice, a chance to explain, question, critique, collaborate, and influence the process, they will feel more ownership. Then, you can allow them to make meaningful decisions about process, tools, and demonstrations of mastery.

There are nonnegotiable things: Common standards, high expectations, and meaningful student agency.

Student agency doesn't mean allowing students to do what they want. It's about giving them belonging (connecting their experiences, cultural traditions, and values), contribution (letting them share their ideas), and reflection (generating evidence about their own learning).

Choice is powerful, but only when it is paired with clear goals, scaffolds, feedback, and reflection.

If they can only follow instructions, it is limited to that one problem. If they have built agency, they can navigate unfamiliar situations. (Personal note: I tell Matt frequently that he is not just an instructor but an educator. Instructors are good in the class I'm in. Matt has taught me enough to say, "I can't do that today. I'll do this instead" because he has taught me what was important about the movement to begin with so I know what the effect of replacing it with a different movement would be.)

Example of building agency: After a student has tried out a strategy, ask student, "Which strategy would you use next time and why?"

A simple way of including students AND building clarity: Rather than telling them what the objective is for the day, post it and ask a student to read it aloud. Have someone explain why you are doing what you are doing today. Then, give success criteria and have them say it when you refer back to it.

Words of the week: Begin the week with vocabulary that students will be hearing a lot that week. When it comes up again, ask them to connect it.

Keep asking them to explain why something matters. When they answer a question, follow up with, "And why is that important?"


Closing Keynote III: Getting Them to Eat Peas When All They Want Is Ice Cream: Student Autonomy, Agency, and Adversity by John Almarode, PhD

Personal Bias Alert: John is one of my favorite people on the entire planet we call Earth. I will gush throughout the notes that follow. You have been warned.

What to do next?

What does relatedness, competence, and autonomy look like in a classroom?

Engagement is not binary. It is a continuum.

Looking engaged is not engagement. A student who is looking out a window may be daydreaming, but he may also be thinking about what you are saying. A kid can be looking at you and smiling and be completely checked out.

Disruptive ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Driving

Disruptive --------Checked out -------------- Compliance ---------Happily Participating -----------Driving




There are many factors that will affect where you are on the continuum.

Students who are driving their own learning know what they are trying to learn. They know what the next step is. The reflect on what they did. (Personal note: My table mate and I both agreed that we were always Invested when we were in school. We wanted other people to Drive.)

Mental Model of Teaching
What we say we want is often in contradiction to what we do. We do in our classrooms reflects our mental model more than what we say we believe about our mental model.

He gave a prompt about finding yourself on a desert island. The answers were based on your view of the situation. If you viewed as being stranded and needing to survive, your list was different than if you viewed it as vacation.

If we view students as talented little asset filled human beings we will make different decisions than if we view them as empty vessels who are passive absorbers of information.

We have to have mental models to survive in complex environments. But if they are inaccurate, they lead to poor behavior. The models can evolve, but they are resistant to change, so they evolve in small ways. It is really important to make sure they aren't based on poor evidence, biases, and stereotypes.

We can tweak the environment to increase motivation, but our mental models sometimes make us resistant to doing that because we assume it is the student.

Monitoring Climate and Culture
We want to create opportunities for ALL learners to engage. 

Goldlilocks Principle
  • The right amount of competence. They have too much, they'll be bored. Too little, and they can't even try.
  • The right amount of relatedness. Too much and it's just a party. Too little, and they don't care.
  • The right amount of autonomy. Too much, and you don't learn the curriculum. Too little, and they feel too devalued to care.
How do we implement it? (Not a checklist. Things that
  1. Tasks and experiences that encourage student dialogue
  2. Supportive relational conditions
  3. Shared agreements about success (clarity)
  4. Cognitive, metacognitive, and emotional self-regulation skills ("Learning is not the outcome it is the means to the outcome of creating whole people)
  5. Peer supports built in
  6. Build student leadership skills

Can I describe what is meant by student engagement?

Can I explain the relationship between my mental model and what happens in my classroom?

Can I being to design an environment that fosters and nurtures motivated learners?



Friday, November 13, 2026

Learning and the Brain - Austin - Raw Notes for Friday

Note: These are raw notes, taken in real time during the presentation. They have not been edited. I also have a tendency to add my own thoughts as I take notes. While I try to make note of that, I sometimes don't know the difference. If you find something offensive, don't blame the speaker because it might be my thoughts and not theirs.

Keynote I: Motivation and Myth: Science-Based Strategies to Boost Motivation in Yourself and Your Students by Wendy S. Grolnick, PhD

Book: Motivation Myth Busters

Motivation is a word that gets used in a number of ways, but they tend to miss the complexity. 

Ben Heddy and Frank Worrell are her partners in addressing the myths about motivation (The Myth Busters Team)

Motivation is the energy that we direct toward an activity. It's a process (an internal one), not a thing. It doesn't come from an external source, like persuasion or coercion. We don't motivate other people, but we can set the conditions that harness their internal motivation.

Myths: Beliefs that are either totally inconsistent with science or that are partially true but have incomplete understanding. 

  1. Some people are motivated and others aren't.
  2. Rewards increase motivation.
  3. Competition always increases motivation.
  4. Motivation alone is enough for success
  5. Visualizing success will lead to success.
  6. We should wait for motivation to strike.
  7. People are aware of how good they are at things.
  8. Structure interferes with motivation.
  9. Telling people they are smart increases motivation.
  10. Motivation is determined primarily by individual characteristics.
Motivational challenges
  • Being unclear about the "rules of the game"
  • Past success without effort
  • Drawing conclusions from limited data
  • Have relied on other to motivate them, so they lack self-regulation
  • Have done better than their peers in the past
Myth 1. Some people are motivated and others aren't.
You are motivated. So is everyone else. The question is "What are they motivated to do?" We tend to attribute our own motivation to circumstances (You are looking outward). We tend to attribute other people's motivations to internal personal issues. We sometimes pay less attention to unmotivated students or pressure them more because we feel inclined to light a fire. Both will backfire.

Motivation is context specific and task specific. 
  • Self Determination Theory - People have a need for autonomy, competence, and relatedness
  • Interest Theory - Interest can be developed by linking material to student interests
  • Expectancy Value Theory - Material must be meaningful or valuable. Can you link it their goals?
Myth 2. Rewards Increase Motivation
They will sometimes change behavior, but they rarely change internal drive. Student will do just enough to get the reward and no more. Learning is superficial. Rewards do not change anything in the long term and they stop being interested once the reward is given. They undermine the intrinsic motivation and learn less (and are less creative) at the end.

Provide choices and meaningful tasks. Engage them in problem solving. Emphasize the learning, not the grade.

Myth 3. Competition Always Increases Motivation
Competition can actually be demotivating when it comes to learning. They are motivated to win rather than to learn. Students who are not competitive will tune out. The student who loses may have done well, but they will still get the message that they didn't do well. 

Cooperation results in better performance that competition. If there is any perception of unfairness in competition, motivation is undermined. It is most demotivating if it is focused on beating an opponent rather than performing the task. Put students into cooperative groups rather than competitive ones. 

Myth 4: Motivation is Enough for Success
You need skills and strategies for success in addition to motivation. Motivation ALONE sets them up for failure. That then kills their motivation. 

Teach self regulation: Encourage them to set goals and plan strategies to reach them. Explicitly teach time management and organization. Teach student to monitor, evaluate, and modfiy strategies.

Myth 5: Visualizing Success Will Lead to Success
Your brain feels like you have already gotten there, so it ignores the work that is necessary to do it. It feels good, so you do not engage in the process that should lead to feeling good (You got it without earning it).

Have students focus on process rather than outcome.

Myth 6: We Should Wait for Motivation to Strike
No. Just no.

Start doing it; motivation follows. Do something - anything - to get started.

Myth 7: People are Aware of How Good They Are at Things
People need help assessing their abilities. Most people think they are better than they are, so they fail and then feel awful or stop trusting their instructor. Those who are under-confident don't even want to try. Focus feedback on what a student can DO to improve.

Myth 8: Structure Decreases Motivation
Students feel helpless when they don't know the rules or guidelines. there is no sense of safety that they are doing what they should do, so they don't know where to start.

Structure and autonomy are not at odds. Structure gives the fences within which they can make autonomous decisions. Students know when they have achieved competence, so they feel clear on things. Allow input where possible, but the student is not completely in charge.

Myth 9: Telling People They are Smart Increases Motivation
Students misattribute their success or failure to ability rather than strategy. That gives them nowhere to go when they fail. A student who believes they succeed just because they are smart doesn't think they need to try, so their motivation is decreased. 

Praise effort and strategies, not anything internal to the child.

Myth 10: Motivation is Determined Mostly by Individual Characteristics
Environment plays more role than inherent qualities. Do students feel the system is stacked against them? Do they see people like them represented in the fields they want to go into. Any perception of a structural barrier decreases motivation.

Keynote II: Rekindling Your Child’s Motivation by Ellen B. Braaten, PhD

Books: Bright Kids Who Couldn't Care Less and Bright Kids Who Can't Keep Up

Her expertise is in ADHD and slow processing speed, not motivation. But those kids were being described as lazy by parents, so she decided to find out what more was going on.

Could behaviors be indicative of depression? (It makes everything feel "meh.") But that didn't seem to explain it either.

"The absence of mental illness doesn't mean the presence of mental health."

Kids with slow processing speeds often have difficulty with executive function. The world rewards quickness, so kids with slow processing speeds might be demotivated because they are out of sync with the speed of the world.

Is there more going on

Motivation Theories: Instinct, incentive, Drive, Arousal

  • Instinct theory - We are born with innate biological tendencies that help us survive. What is the role of biology in motivation? 
  • Incentive theory - Not all incentives work equally well with each child. Some incentive can be helpful. Too much is weirdly demotivating.
  • Drive theory - We have a need to reduce internal tension. Do they reduce tension by completing it or by not turning in an incomplete assignment?
  • Arousal theory - People take actions to increase or decrease levels of arousal (we actually want to be in the middle to maintain homeostasis). What do students do when they are bored? What do they do when they are overwhelmed?
Three components of motivation
  1. Activation - Getting started
  2. Persistence - Maintaining Attention
  3. Intensity - Not allowing energy to diminish
Motivation is like fire. It needs air, fuel, and heat. 
  • Air - Do they have the space they need to take ownership?
  • Fuel - Do they have the skills they need to support their interests?
  • Heat - Are they exposed to activities which spark interest?

How do you know they don't care? What signs are you seeing?

Are your expectations reasonable for your child? Are they developmentally appropriate? Are they so high the child can't meet them? Are they so low that you are sending them a message that you think they aren't capable?

What has changed recently? Could those changes be influencing their motivation level?

Is there a skills deficit? It is hard to be motivated in a class if you can't read. 

Pressure to achieve is demotivating - Competition, high pressure to get into the best college, perfectionism, social comparison. (It's not longer good enough to volunteer; now colleges want to see you start a non-profit.)

Some kids don't even want to go to college, but we expect them to, so they are demotivated from the things that would get them there to try to make it happen. 

There are barriers to college that aren't visible, but they influence motivation. We assume everyone is going to go whether or not it is right for them. We want to make it an option for everyone, but we want to recognize that some kids will take a different option.  

How can we help?

  • Consider different components of motivation - Where are they getting stuck? Address that thing.
  • What they are good at is not always what they enjoy. Finding the intersection is where they find motivation. Mismatching them is demotivating. 
    • Consider their aptitudes - What are they good at? What are they not good at? (False praise isn't helpful; be realistic.) It's not just academics and sports; do they have a strength like empathy or trustworthiness?
    • Consider their pleasure - What do they enjoy? What gives them intrinsic joy? When are they smiling the most. What makes them curious? On the flip side, what bores them? Do they need to feel independent by rejecting what adults want from them? Allow for play without a product; allow some boredom so they have to find things to do. Cultivate gratitude. Stop over-scheduling so they have space to engage in the things that bring them pleasure.
    • Consider their practice - What do they like to repeat regularly? What do they return to without prompting? What do they wish they could learn (and what would it take to get good at that)?
What gets in the way of practice?
  • Disraction
  • Tedium
  • Lack of past success
  • Overscheduling
  • Inappropriate feedback

When should you use Extrensic Motivation?

  • To get the to try something they might like 
  • When there is an impending deadline
  • When they need to be reminded how hard they are working
Sparingly and unexpectedly to celebrate an achievement (not if-then but now-that)

The goal is self-efficacy - the belief that you are capable (not good at everything - that's narcissism) and able to influence your own success

Concurrent Session B: Micro-Learning for K-12 Classrooms: Creating Short Burst of Instruction Towards Mastery by Douglas B. Fisher, PhD

Design an instruction framework that allows to teachers to segment their instructions (chunking - but he doesn't like that word)

Showed five options (all are right for different reasons) and asked you to say, "I like (fill in number) because (fill in reason). Giving a sentence frame increased the chance of success, but it did not lower the rigor. 

Showed video of a person teaching how to do the backflip with each part segmented. If you have scaffolds, but you don't systematically remove them, they are not learning. Learning is doing it without help eventually. 

Chunking isn't making lessons shorter; it's sequencing.

TIRES (Tasks, Input, Responses, Evidence, Success) - The order doesn't matter. You can rotate your tires.

T - What do students need to do to generate evidence? Tasks exist to produce evidence, not to fill time. Poor tasks lead to misleading data or you need to change the task. How much time does it take; is it worth the time required? Tasks should require students to practice, apply, consolidate, and/or explore. Practice automates processes so they aren't in the way of working memory. Often you don't know what you think until you have explained it. 

I - What instruction honors strengths while supporting growth? Show it. Model it. Make it clear. Don't let input be the entire lesson, or it will crowd out response and consolidation. How many minutes of teacher input does a concept need? Depends on the concept. (Personal thought - It doesn't have to be this then that. Input and response can be in a constant square dance.) Teacher modeling doesn't have to mean a teacher monologue. Think aloud can be think along if you build a good story.

R - How does the student show growth and understanding? Rehearsal and retrieval are key to making learning permanent. Students must respond to bring information to long term memory. Random calling on students will fairly distribute practice, but if you use it alone, it disengages the high level students. Student volunteers leads to 6 kids dominating the conversation if you only use it. Teacher choice (not random) allows for interesting ideas to come forward, but you have to be careful about picking the same kids over and over. Universal response (whiteboards) allows you to hear from everyone. Varying all of these is ideal.

E - What are we noticing about how the student learns, engages, makes meaning?  What do I want students to learn? What evidence would I accept to verify learning? Assessment exists on nested cycles. Short term (happening now) affecting medium term (a week or so) with an eye to the long term (four weeks or more). If they aren't aligned (writing an exit ticket in the short cycle doesn't prepare them for a multiple choice question in the long cycle), it doesn't give you the data you need. They have to practice what they will be assessed on. If they are going to do something in a certain way on the final, that way of doing it must show up at least in the medium cycle.

S - What does it mean to be successful? Has the teacher identified what successful learning looks like? Incremental success criteria provide a ladder for students. Four success criteria per hour is the standard in order to increase the frequency that student experience success and to increase segmenting the lesson. Meet the first one in the first 10 minutes of class to increase motivation for the rest of the period. Change "I can" statements to "Can I" statements to require the student to generate an answer. 

When you experience success, your likelihood of working hard on the next task goes up because your bran remembers what it felt like to be successful.

Takeaways

  • Chunking lessons reduces cognitive overload and improves learning. 
  • Each chunk should be evaluated for success
  • Evidence of learning should be used to design the next steps

Keynote III: The Power of Meaning to Motivate: Aligning Our Purpose, Belong, and Values for Success by Emily Esfahani Smith, MA

Book: The Power of Meaning: Crafting a Life that Matters, TED talk.

Victor Frankl, a concentration camp survivor, wrote Man's Search for Meaning. Many people in concentration camps gave up hope; there was nothing left to live for. But there were some who were more apt to survive because they felt that life was meaningful in spite of it all. Between WWI and WWII, he had been working with young people. There was a high suicide rate during the time report cards came out. Students felt that there life was over if they shamed their families and had no future if they didn't do well in school. He set up a therapy practice - logotherapy -  in Vienna and helped them find meaning outside of achievement to confront the problem. 

Meaning is as important for mental health as food is for physical health.

Valuing happiness and achievement for their own sake leads to lower happiness, lower achievement, and despair. It must be connected to meaning. Meaning includes significance, purpose, and coherence.

  • Significance - my life matters
  • Purpose - I am working toward something valuable
  • Coherence - My life makes sense to me
Enjoyment fades, but meaning lasts. It's the difference between, "I like doing this" and "This is important and worth my time."

Belonging, Purpose, Transcendence, and Storytelling are the four pillars of a meaningful life.
  • Belonging - Being known and valued for who we intrinsically are and knowing and valuing others for who they are (not for what we do, what we know, or who we love/hate) We underestimate how good it will feel for someone to receive a compliment and overestimate how awkward it might be to do, so we tend to hold it back. Give students opportunities to be vulnerable and give compliments or writing gratitude letters for Thanksgiving. 
  • Purpose - When we do something that matters, we are more motivated to work hard at it, even if it is difficult or dirty work. (Personal note: I found this when I was a janitor. It's gross work, but it needs to be done for the good of other people.) We tend to think of our purpose with a capital P. (It's our job or our major), but a purposeful life includes our attitude about daily activities, like household chores. Ask students to identify a problem they care about and ask them how they can help contribute. Have them write about a purpose for learning, and they will enter it with a better mindset.
  • Transcendence - Connecting ourselves to awe and the beauty of the world. When we connect to something much bigger than ourselves (Personal note: when I was in Africa and saw what the night sky actually looks like for the first time, I couldn't get enough of it). In a study about awe, students were shown video clips that inspired, either awe, joy, or another emotion. They were then given a gift card for participating and told they could keep it or donate it to a refugee family. Those who were exposed to awe were more likely to donate it.
  • Storytelling - The story that you are telling about yourself. How did you become who you are, and where are you going? Ask students what story they want to have. What is a future worth working toward? The story we tell isn't just about who we are now; it shapes who we become.

Meaning lies in ordinary moments. We have no idea how far reaching their impact will be.

Concurrent Sessions C: 

Desirably Difficult: The Counterintuitive Science of Learning by Veronica X. Yan, PhD

How do we know when people are learning? What are the reliable indicators?

Bjork and Bjork Artist Painting Styles experiment - Blocked presentation (all of the same artist grouped together) or interleaved (random order). Then student is showed a painting and asked which artist it is. (They may also get feedback after they answer as they go.) People report that blocked presentation helps them learn better, but interleaved presentation actually produced a better result. Classes who struggle with interleaving more DURING class that those who had an easy time with blocked presentation do better on their TESTS (given 24 hours later) than those who find learning easy during the initial presentation.

Forgetting is normal, but we can reduce forgetting by making the brain work harder during learning. This is not saying to make things as hard as possible or to throw problems at students and let them flounder. It's about finding the sweet spot of challenging the brain so it responds with strengthening. (Personal note: Lifting heavy weights makes you feel weaker WHILE you are doing it, but it makes you stronger OVER TIME. Lifting light weights makes you feel comfortable in the moment, but it doesn't build strength over time.) 

Learning is gradual. It is almost never "one and done."

Goal: Connect, coherent knowledge that is accessible over time

We cannot copy and paste what is in our brain to student brains. We cannot directly observe the structures inside our students' heads. They must produce both to learn and to show us that they have learned. 

"Learning results from what the student does and thinks and only from what the student does and thinks. The teacher can advance learning only by influencing what the student does to learn."- Herb Simon

Interleaving draw attention to the features that distinguish between concepts, making it most useful for learning about related or confusable concepts. Blocking draw attention to features that tie a concept together, helping you get to the underlying structure beyond the surface features (like diffusion). Start with blocking to get down individual concepts; then practice interleaved to compare and contrast similar concepts in order to differentiate them from each other. 

Life comes at you interleaved. 

To be useful, information can't just go in. It has to be retrievable, and we practice that by spacing retrieval to support memory.

Three study techniques were compared

  • Re-read
  • Concept map with notes open
  • Two rounds of recall (Write down everything you can remember, re-read, write down everything you can remember again)
Concept mapping was no better than re-reading. Two rounds of retrieval was much better.

Retrieval practice is best when it is
  • Low or no stkes
  • Appropriate to the level of processing
  • Effortful
  • Spaced and varied
When is the best time to retrieve? After it has left your working memory. Ideally, it would be just before you forget it, but we don't know when that is. (Personal note: My advice to students was to delay 30 minutes between the first couple of times. Then, make it a few hours. Then, make it the next day. Then skip a day.)

Show Your Work: Motivating Students With the Science of Learning by Beth Hawks - No notes here because I was teaching the session, but you can get the slides at my website - thelearninghawk.com 

Thursday, November 12, 2026

Learning and the Brain - Austin - Raw Notes for Thursday

Note: These are raw notes, taken in real time during the presentation. They have not been edited. I also have a tendency to add my own thoughts as I take notes. While I try to make note of that, I sometimes don't know the difference. If you find something offensive, don't blame the speaker because it might be my thoughts and not theirs.

Keynote I: The Science of Motivating Young People by David S. Yeager, PhD

Book 10 to 25: The Science of Motivating Young People

DARE increased drug use in schools. Anti-bullying campaigns result in more bullying, not less. Teenagers don't change their behavior when they sit in a session where we "grown-splain" things to them. You can't expect them to think about their future. "The reward for working hard in a math class is to take a harder math class next year so that some day you can impress a stranger and get into college and maybe be able to afford a house in your 30s."

The feeling of humiliation never feels as bad as it does in adolescence. The pride of having someone take you seriously never feels quite as good as it does during that time. They have a drive for status and respect.

A person they don't know (DARE representative, outside speaker) makes them resist, but a mentor who takes them seriously is someone they will work hard for. Mindset interventions given by a trusted person can change their behavior because they believe you when you tell them that challenges can help them or that there is purpose in their learning. A trusted mentor can make them believe they can get smarter. You help them earn status, belonging, and pride. 

Some ways of framing growth mindset doesn't appeal to them at all, but reframing it can be powerful in getting them to pay attention.

Without Appropriate Growth Mindset Intervention 
        Challenging class --> I must be dumb --> Giving Up

Without Appropriate Growth Mindset Intervention 
        Challenging class --> I am getting smart at this --> Resilience and Persistence

Changing an deeply emotionally held personal belief is not helped with a higher volume of rational arguments. Your mind puts up "antibodies" to a direction confrontation of that belief. Coming in sideways will help.  (Future students might struggle with some of the things you are struggling with. Can you help us create a way to help those students? Give student testimonials of people who have "figured it out.")

Does a short message given at a critical time impact performance over time? It took four years to crunch the data of almost 13000 students in 59 school nationwide. Low achieving students were impacted 3 percentage points by intervention. High achieving students were impacted 0.5 percentage points. There was fade out from students who were initial enthusiastic but didn't get ongoing support. Those who were in higher resource schools (not only those with higher economic resources but higher social resources) didn't see the same fade out. The ongoing support has a recursive effect, but that cannot happen if there are teachers who don't support growth in their students. The teacher's mindset can amplify or quash the students' mindsets.  This feeds into the status/respect hypothesis. 

When adults turn intellectual issues into character flaws, students completely check out and become unwilling to learn from that teacher. He has interfered with their status/respect. Having a growth mindset poster won't overcome the teacher embarrassing the kid in front of his peers.

The grading and testing policies must match the rhetoric. Do they provide opportunities for recouping points after they have said, "Mistakes are your friend because they help you improve?" Do their messages match their opportunities?

Teacher PD is hard because the teacher feels like they are being unfairly blamed for something they are good at. They get defensive because of how many times they are told they are supposed to be doing something differently. 

Values-Aligned Argument for Teachers - 

  1. Adolescents are developmentally primed to be hyper attuned to signals of respect or disrepect from adults.
  2. Teachers' fixed mindset messages, even if unintentional pereceved as disrepectful and lead adolescents to disengage
  3. Teachers' growth mindset messages and opportunities communicate respect for students' learning potential are reciprocated with enthusiastic engagement.
  4. By having deeply engaged students, the teacher will gain respct and admiration of their colleagues.

Teacher interventions for those who previously held a fixed mindset resulted in 50% reduction in teacher burnout rates and a 0.25 standard deviation improvement in Satisfaction With Life.

Keynote II: Visible Teaching: A Reframing of "Visible Learning" and a Call to Arms by David Daniel, PhD and Conference Chair

There's evidence for everything. Interventions that work in controlled studies in the lab don't always work in classrooms. Until there is evidence from practice, we shouldn't be mandating their practice.

Teachers are exhausted from stuff being thrown at them from the people who are supposed to be on their side. Teachers aren't being evaluated by how much the students learn but on things that can be seen quickly by someone coming by with a clipboard.

Teachers are being treated as waiters (deliver what someone else did) rather than cooks (people who know ingredients and are capable of mixing it well). They are being audited for the presence of named techniques rather than the quality of their implementation. 

Hattie's Visible Learning shouldn't be treated as a checklist. David asked him, "Would it come out differently if you had limited it to studies done in classrooms?" At that time, almost none were. Taking a research finding and PRESCRIBING it in a classroom ignores the reality of the classroom. 

If you implement something without knowing how it works, you can't adapt it to your class. This leads to a lot of wasted time and resources and de-professionalizes teachers. It subverts scientific progress because we focus on how rather than why. 

"Best Practices" is a faith based term, and we cannot know that it is better than the alternatives. There are "promising principles," but until they produce results in your classroom, they are nothing. Teachers don't need "this thing and nothing else;" they need a toolbox of options to choose from and the ability to decide what might work well in their classroom. Since nothing works in EVERY context, adaptation is really important.

Lectures have been maligned in the literature, but in a comparison between a good lecture and a group activity, the lecture won. The researcher couldn't find someone to publish it. 

Let's move from the "best practices" trap into a "promising principles" paradigm. 

  • Best practices stops at surface features, reduces adaptation, and treats research findings as a mandate. 
  • Promising principles explains WHY strategies work, enables responsible adaption, and focuses on impact rather than appearance.
Principles are transferable. Practices are context specific. 

When you look at the Hattie list, the effective practices produced meaningful immediate opportunities for feedback. The ineffective ones don't. If you can't tell whether something is effective in the moment you are teaching, you can't adapt. It's not the technique itself that is making itself effective; it's the data it provides the teacher that she can then interpret and act on. 

Your class becomes co-constructed because you responding to feedback from each other.

Teachers must: Notice --> Interpret --> Evaluate --> Respond

Stop asking "What should I implement" and start asking "How will I know whether my teaching is producing its intended effects while there is still time to act?"

"Evidence-based" is how we sell supplements. "Evidence demonstrated" is how we sell medicines. Teachers are in charge of demonstrating how researched practice work.

The practice of "skin to skin contact" that is being used in every hospital as a method of bonding is evidence based because it came from observation of goats and their kids. It has never been demonstrated to be true in humans, but it is being taught in med schools, nurse trainings, and delivery rooms. It wasn't tested in humans before it was adopted. Once it was studied, it turned out not to make a difference in humans at all. (This isn't trivial because it has done real emotional damage to people who cannot do it - adoptive parents, babies who are taken to the NICU. People felt they had missed their one and only chance to have a bonding experience.) 

"Give a teacher a strategy, they will have a lesson plan. Teach them why it works, and they will have a career."

Personal thought: If you know they why behind the how, you can translate it into a millions hows.

Concurrent Session A: The Architecture of Motivation: Why Teachers Matter in the Age of AI by Micah Gottlieb

Note: My original plan had been to see Peps McCrae during this time. Wednesday night, he made the announcement that he was joining the Alpha Schools team. I didn't have time in the 20 hours between his announcement and his session to process my feelings of disillusionment. I haven't given up on Peps, but I couldn't make it happen by the time of his session. So, I am in this one instead. 

Think of a time when you learned how to do something difficult. What made you stick with it when things got difficult? 

How do we know learning has happened? The product turned in by a student can look good without their having learned anything doing it. (This has always been true because of parental involvement. Now it can be that they just prompted an AI to do it.)

Engagement does not necessarily equal performance, and performance is not always indicative of learning. They are related to each other, but they are not equivalent. 

Learning requires thinking (retrieval, generation, explanation, revision, and application). Does AI strengthen these processes or replace them? 

Conditions for Learning Motivation

  1. Can I admit I'm confused?
  2. Do I have value here?
  3. Can I improve and grow?
  4. Do I have a meaningful role in my learning?
1. In a classroom, does your student feel safe taking risks? Do they asks questions, reveal confusion, or offer answers if they are uncertain? Are they able to show you they are struggling without fear. (Does AI allow them to hide confusion?)

2.  In a classroom, do students feel like they matter? Do they believe they have something to offer? What significance do you impart to them about their own presences? There is a difference between a student who is disengaged and a student who is hesitant to participate, even though the behaviors look similar. The students is always wondering, "Would anyone notice if I weren't here or stopped participating?" (Does AI exacerbate a feeling of insignificance by putting out good looking work that the student had little contribution to creating?)

3. In a classroom, is feedback telling students what was wrong or what can be improved? Do they trust you enough to accept your feedback? Progress creates motivation, which leads to more progress.  Feedback must be timed in such a way that it can be acted upon.  Do they have the opportunity to revise after trustworthy feedback is given? Help students recognize that learning is effortful and that the feeling of effort is often uncomfortable, but it leads to progress. (AI gives feedback instantly, but is it trustworthy feedback? AI produces work that looks finished whether or not progress has been made.)

4. Do your students feel they have the ability to make meaningful choices - not decorative choices, like font or color, but meaningful choices like the strategies they will use or the explanations and justifications they will give. What decisions belong to the learner? (AI removes a lot of the decisions students might make because it makes them without input.)

Psychological needs that shape motivation: Agency, Competence, and Relatedness (Self determination theory) 

Learning is strengthen when learners actively DO something with the information. (retrieval, generation, explanation, correction, revision, and application)

What is the students' cognitive responsibility? Where is it okay to offload (We often use notes, reminders, calendars)? When should it not be offloaded? The tool's role depends on the goal (If the goal is computation, a calculator should not be used. If the goal is data analysis, a calculator allows you to free up working memory for the task of analysis).

To evaluate the method of using a tool, you must ask. "Is the learner getting better, or is only the assignment getting better?"

Study on AI usage is math learning. The result was that performance was 48% better on practice problems, but 17% worse on the exam. Students were overconfident. Doing the same process with an AI tutor (hints only without problem solving) showed no difference in the exam performance over the control group (so it reduced the harm but didn't provide any benefit to the learning). 

Learning experience shape our beliefs about ourselves? Do they have (HERO) hope efficacy, optimism, and resilience? (Personal note: If students leave an experience believing they NEED AI to learn, do they stop believing that THEY are capable of learning?) 

Five questions for Designing AI-Supported Learning
  1. What should the student learn to do?
  2. What thinking does the student need to practice?
  3. What will the technology do and what will it replace?
  4. What human support will help the student engage and make progress?
  5. What evidence will show that the student has learned?
Personal Note: All teachers have always had to ask 1, 2, and 5 (and sort of 4 but we wouldn't have worded it that way). If we don't use AI, we don't have to ask 3. 

What will students do differently?  What evidence will you look for about learning?

Why do teachers still matter? They matter more than ever in the age of AI. They create the conditions, engage students in thinking, motivate, help learning last, and help students grow. People create the conditions that create more capable people.

Then, he sang a song he wrote about why teachers matter more than ever.

Keynote III: Breaking Bad (Habits): Catalyzing Metacognition and Effective Strategies for Better Learning by Regan A. R. Gurung, PhD

The biggest challenge he sees at the university level is students studying the wrong way and forming bad habits.

What are the bad habits?

Social media use and AI use (65% of adults and 78% of students) - Half of adults and 60% of students are using it for support and companionship. At least 54% of students are using it to help with schoolwork and search for information. 

Students who have never used AI to summarize a text have way higher scores than those who used it once or twice per week for that purpose. Those who prompted it "to help me learn" performed about the same as those who didn't use it at all. It leads to faster work (and higher grades if the teacher is only grading the product), but it leads to less learning. 

Habits are usually the result of cues (Personal note: Drew Dyke's book, Your Future Self Will Thank You, gives great advice on cueing). Depending on the habit, it can take 8 days to 3 months. Breaking a bad habit can take 1 to 65 days. Changing the cues helps to change the habit. The best predictor behavior is past behavior. Creating stable cues help create the habit. Exercise or study or whatever habit you want to create at the same time in the same place (unless you become bored with that and becomes demotivating, the changing the cue will help you keep your habit). 

Decide to act --> Self regulate --> Repeat behavior --> Cue association

Breaking the cue can change the cycle. Putting your workout clothes and shoes in an easily accessible and visible space makes you more likely to work out. Keeping junk food out of the house will prevent you from reaching for them. Lower the barrier to action for studying by putting the books in a visible place.

What do we know about learning that can help?

Behavior is complex. There are different predictors. The actions of student makes up 50% of the determining factors. The teacher is 25%. Pears and home are each 5%. The remaining 15% is made up of all of the other factors in their lives.

To paraphrase The Princess Brain, "Learning is pain, highness. Anyone who tells you otherwise is selling something." Learning is hard work.

Learning needs attention. For well over half the time in class, they are texting and using Snapchat (a little less for other socials). The number one person texting them is their mom. They are using them even more during study time. They are more engaged and happier with fewer digital distractions. They often don't know how to stop using it and need our help. 

Students are using ineffective techniques.

But even the best techniques can have small effect sizes on average because of the complexities of HOW they employ them. 

The effectiveness of ANY technique depends on the variables involved (quality sleep, home stability, nutrition, fight with a friend).

Students often know what is effective, but it requires too much time, effort, and planning when other things that are more fun are out there, even though they know they are ineffective. 

AI could/does make this worse. Cognitive surrender, AI dependency, AI summaries halt brain processing (business pay to be included in the summary, so your sources are biased). People assume it is good if they don't understand it (Emperor's new clothes) 

Thinking fast and slow - Neither system is engaged when cognition is surrendered to AI. 

Human connection is irreplaceable. 

Keynote IV: Motivation + Metacognition by Bradley K. Busch, MSc

We are given the definition of metacognition "Thinking about thinking." It's technically correct, but it doesn't really tell us anything.

Better definition - "The ability to monitor, direct, and review our own learning."

Reasons for Procrastination

  • Planning Fallacy - People underestimate how long it will take to do things, so they start too late to complete them.
  • Starting is harder than continuing - Starting from a blank page makes it nearly impossible to finish (Car wash loyalty card example) - Give students something to start with, and they will complete it better than if you expect them to generate it from the beginning.  
  • Not knowing what to do in order to get started - Asking students to ask three questions resulted in doing better studying.
    • Which resources do I need to help me study?
    • Why are those resources helpful?
    • How will I use this resource?
Once students are doing a task, how do I help them stay focused?
  • Motivation is not a predictor of behavior because it is too fluid. An early success will help sustain it. An early failure will kill it quickly.
  • We overestimate what we will do. We have good intentions but life gets in the way. 
  • Our environment has a massive impact on how we feel and behave. Manipulating the environment results in behavior change far more than rational explanations or threats of consequences. (How do you get people to take the stairs? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2lXh2n0aPyw)

Resilience is something you nurture and develop with a high challenge and high support environment. It isn't something you teach in isolation.

The Cycling Experiment (Stone, et al)

The Marshmallow Experiment has been interpreted wrongly since the 70s. People have thought that the ability to delay gratification was a genetically determined factor. In the updated version, one group sees their teacher lie to someone while they waited to go into the room with the marshmallow. If the environment was reliable, the child waited 10 times longer than those who saw the teacher lie. Our ability to delay gratification is not predetermined; it is based on environment. (Takeaway: If the teacher is credible and trustworthy, the student will work harder and take feedback more effectively.)

What happens after a failure?
Teachers were asked to predict how a student would do a year after failing a test.

Those with a growth mindset said, "It's too early to tell." Those with a fixed mindset predicted a low performance a year from now because the student had low ability.

Then they asked the teachers what they would say to the students. Those with a growth mindset broke down the next steps into strategies. Those with a fixed mindset went for a comfort approach. Students felt that the comfort confirmed that they were just bad at the thing because the teacher had low expectations of them. It lowered their motivation. Those who got strategies were more motivated. Teaching the process has more impact on motivation than any "motivational" technique.

How do you strike a balance between comfort and strategy. 

Sunday, November 8, 2026

What I Learned About Education From an Aqua Fit Class

I'm in a pretty consistent routine with my workouts at the Y, but occasionally, I change things up when one of my regular instructors is out of town. Given that I swim just well enough to avoid death, I didn't think I would like taking Aqua Fit. But when my Livestrong group had theirs, I joined them and found that it was not the same as swimming (the instructor got into the water with her glasses on) and that it was a pretty good time. But that was a demonstration with only nine people in the water; so I decided to take my regular instructor's absence as an opportunity to see what it was like as an actual class. As usual, I learned some things about myself but also some things that might apply to classrooms.

The influence of others - When I got in the water, I chose a spot with great intention. I didn't want to be in deep water, but I also knew I couldn't remain at waist level. I wanted to be mid-pack, not too close to the instructor but not on the back row. It turns out that it didn't much matter which spot I chose because when twenty-four people started moving, the water started moving, and the water moved me. There were times I was much closer to the person next to me than I intended to be, and at some point without knowing how I got there, I was on the front row. No one was moving me on purpose, but as they affected the water, the water affected me.

It's not hard to see where I'm going with this when it comes to classrooms. I've never experienced peer pressure myself - truly. Even when I was a teenager, I was outspoken enough that my friends knew what I would and would not do and didn't even try to get me to do things they knew I didn't want to. But that doesn't mean I wasn't influenced by "the water." As a girl in the 80s, I had a spiral perm and high bangs and wore a lot of denim. I listened to Michael and Whitney, and I watched Saved By the Bell. It was just part of being in the water in the 80s.

This can be used for good or ill in your classroom. We are creatures who follow social norms. If we feel we belong to a group, we will do what the group does. Watch this hilarious experiment from Brain Games to see it in action. You classroom is like that. Studies have found that attention is contagious. Students seated near someone who is engaged in their work will respond by engaging in theirs (weirdly, even if the initiator is behind them out of their eye line). Classes where the majority of students care about learning will influence the one or two who don't. As teachers, we often make the mistake of highlighting the behavior we want to eliminate rather than the ones we want to reinforce. We say, "I can't believe there are so many of you who didn't turn in your homework." When we do that, we give all of those who didn't turn it in reassurance that they weren't the only one. If we say instead, "Thank you to so many of you for getting your work in on time," we emphasize that the norm is the good behavior.

You know the sign you see in hotel bathrooms that tell you how much water can be saved if you reuse your towel. It doesn't work with very many people. But, in an experiment where they compared messages, signs that said, "Eighty percent of people reuse their towel" did work. People want to believe they belong and will adjust their behavior accordingly. They aren't influenced by the power or popularity of those people, just the number of them; they are affected by "the water."

Lower level but constant tension had results - Most of the time, I take cycle and Body Pump (oh, and Barre with Dana once a week). Body Pump is a class where I work my large muscles with heavy weights. We work one body part at a time. In this particular Aqua Fit class, we used water weights - styrofoam dumbbells that you push down into the water. Depending on the size you chose, you experienced a different amount of resistance from the water. I thought, "I regularly take Body Pump. I'll use the high resistance weights. Thank you." But here's the difference. In Body Pump, there are times when the muscle isn't experiencing tension. In between reps, you are resting your muscle at the top or bottom of the movement. In between sets or during the transition between songs, those muscles are getting a little break. This is not the case in Aqua Fit. Once you have pushed that weight under the water, it is resisted every time in moves in any direction. Even when I was standing still, I was having to push down to keep the weight under the water. I honestly wasn't sure I would get through the entire hour. The next day, I was low key sort from the neck down. I'm used to having very sore big muscles, but the constant tension created soreness in the small muscles I didn't even know I had.

In classrooms, we often focus on big, dramatic learning moments. Exams, high stakes tests, semester projects, etc. Don't get me wrong; those matter. But where does most of the learning happen in your classroom? It happens in the mundane activities you do day to day. It happens when you have students engage in retrieval. It happens when they do practice problems for homework. It happens when they come in after school and have a conversation with you about the things they need help with. The lower level but constant tension is what forms their brains for learning. 

My foot didn't hurt - I have all kinds of problems with my feet. I'd love to blame my age (or perimenopause), but I started wearing orthotics at the age of 24. I stood on concrete floors for 7 hours every day for 25 years. I think I'm finally over plantar fasciitis, but I would honestly take it back to get rid of the metatarsalgia I have now. I've had to stop going up on my toes in Barre and have to readjust my form for several moves in Body Pump (no planks for me). But through an entire hour of Aqua Fit, I didn't even think about my foot. The buoyant nature of water allowed me to put less pressure on my foot and land on it softly.

How are you going to relate this one to education, I hear you asking. Every child has some pain point in their education. For some kids, it's math that makes their "foot hurt." For others, it is English. I loved school, but I just couldn't wrap my head around history. But I had one history teacher, Mr. Watkins, who got me through history classes without "foot pain." Did he show us videos? Not a single one. Did he take us outside and have us throw things at each other to simulate a battle? Nope. He didn't do any of the things that current middle school history teachers do to engage their students. What he did was share his passion. He absolutely loved talking about Winston Churchill, W.E.B. DuBois, and George Washington Carver. He was especially enthralled by the story of Czar Nicholas and Alexandra, and because he was, I was too. In fact, I read the book Nicholas and Alexandra in the 7th grade, which was punching above my weight even for an avid reader like me. In the same way the pool didn't cure my foot problems but gave me some relief from them, Mr. Watkins didn't cure my history problem. I didn't become a great history lover in high school or college, but for the two years I had Mr. Watkins in middle school, I enjoyed learning what he loved. And those topics still intrigue me. If I'm flipping through channels and see Rasputin, I will stop to watch. 

The water stopped being cold - When I first stepped into the pool, I tentatively tested the temperature of the water. It was fine when I was on the first step, but as soon as it hit the skin on my thighs, I was in shock. It felt so cold as I got in up to my chest that I wasn't sure how I could stay for long (By the way, this is heated pool; I'm just a thin blooded Southerner when it comes to temperature). About five minutes into class, I wasn't cold anymore. I might have been sweating, but it's hard to tell in the water. This was partly from exertion (see constant tension above), but it was also because I became accustomed to the temperature of the water.

When we first introduce a new and challenging skill to students, they are sometimes shocked by it. This is not the time to give up or to make it easier. They will grow accustomed to it. I sometimes reminded students that things they find easy now were once difficult for them. As adults, we read signs and notices almost unconsciously, sometimes in our peripheral vision. We forget the work that went into learning how to read. We walk without effort, but it wasn't always that way. Everything that is easy now was once difficult, and the only way through it perseverance. When appropriate, point out to students that they are now doing things they once found difficult. 

Education is sometimes exciting, but most of the time, it is the daily, constant tension of learning, retrieval, and the practice of skills. Keep it up. In time, you will see the results, but it often takes staying in the uncomfortable until it becomes comfortable.

Learning and the Brain - Austin - Raw Notes for Saturday

Note: These are raw notes, taken in real time during the presentation. They have not been edited. I also have a tendency to add my own thoug...