Sunday, August 4, 2024

Be Confident in Your Expertise

I've written several posts over the years about the death of expertise and why it matters.  The reason I wanted to write about it again is that I've seen a disturbing trend in education, a sort of populist approach that reduces teachers to facilitators.  

It started by asking students to teach themselves, reducing the role of the teacher to facilitator.  If you are in the world of education, you have been encouraged to stop being the "sage on the stage" in favor of bing the "guide on the side."  If you aren't in education, you might not know these pithy rhyming phrases, but you might have heard your child's teachers talk about being self-guided, using inquiry methods, or using a constructivist approach.  It all means the same thing - the blind leading the blind while the teacher looks on.  

It might have died the inevitable death of most educational fads had it not been for parents with strong opinions who could find a blog to back them up (yes, I'm aware of the irony here).  My most recent school principal has a degree in curriculum, but she found herself in meetings where she had to defend our curriculum choices to people who read an article on parents.net.schoolstuff.something.  In a world where "elitism" is being progressively looked down on, my ill informed opinion is equal to your highly trained expertise.

Because I am scared of getting caught in traffic jams on my way to work, I leave far to early and end up sitting in the parking lot for 15-20 minutes before my shift.  I usually read in the car, but on Thursday, I found myself fascinated by the landscapers and tree trimmers keeping the area around the outdoor pool maintained.  

The first thing I noticed were the amazing tools these guys have.  I don't know what to call the saw that looks like a very large electric turkey knife, but the blade is as long as I am tall.  And it must be incredibly sharp because they run it along the surface of dense trees and bushes with heavy wood branches, and it cuts through them like they are made of something no more substantial than butter. I don't have access to a tool like that because I don't need it and because it would be dangerous if I tried to use it without expertise.

The second thing I noticed was what they did after running the saw along the surface.  They reached out and shook the bushes.  I don't mean a little vibration.  The entire bush was vigorously shaken.  As an outside observer, it appeared to me to be a violent force, and I wondered why it was necessary.  Then, I watched as they cleaned up all of the leaves and sticks that had been loosened and dropped out of the plant.  If they had not shaken it, it would have looked fine that day, but when the newly detached leaves dried up and turned brown, the trees would have looked worse than before.  They knew exactly what to do to make the pants look better that before and thrive without leaving the waste behind.

Because they are equipped, trained, and experienced, they have both tools and expertise I do not have.  This meant that the way they did their job looked strange to me, but it was the right way to do it.

Teachers do things that may look odd to the outside observer.  Students, parents, and people on the internet have a lot of ideas about education.  I have been in conversations with people who have very strong opinions about what teachers should do, in spite of their not having been in a classroom since 1968.  They think that, because they went to school, they know how school should look.  But that would be a little like me thinking I could inform an auto mechanic on the best way to fix my car just because I know how to drive.

Even within the field, there are varying types of expertise.  I may observe teaching methods that I do not know in disciplines other than my own.  I don't have the first clue how to teach computer coding or foreign language, but the experts in those fields are trained in that kind of pedagogy and can make decisions with a different kind of professional judgment than I have.

Some teachers are shy about asserting their professional judgment, especially in meetings with particularly forceful parents.  Some teachers go too far the other way, believing they should never have to explain themselves to anyone outside their area of expertise.  Neither of these is the right approach.  You make the decisions you do for a reason, and you should be happy to share those reasons because they come from a good place.  You can be open to input without caving to everyone who disagrees.

Teachers, as the school year is about to begin, let me encourage you all to find the confidence to make strong decisions, explain them well, and stand your ground because you have skills, tools, and expertise those arguing with you do not possess.  

Sunday, July 28, 2024

Yes, I Do Have a "Direct Stake in the Future"

Well, this is certainly not what I had planned to write about this week.  I wanted to write some educational wonky stuff in preparation for the coming year.  I generally try to keep this blog about education rather than politics.  But every once in a while, the two worlds overlap, like the debates sparked after school shootings or book banning arguments. Vice presidential candidate JD Vance's comments about childless women qualifies.  As a middle aged single virgin, this is also something on which I feel fairly qualified to offer perspective.

For those who may have been living under a rock for the last week, let me catch you up.  When President Biden stepped away from his run for re-election and endorsed Kamala Harris, the Trump/Vance campaign found itself scrambling for new talking points. They couldn't call her old or question her cognitive abilities, and I guess they didn't have time to research things of substance.  So, what did they go to? She isn't qualified because she hasn't given birth to children.  Setting aside for the moment that none of our Presidents have ever given birth to children because they were men and that George Washington, James Polk, Warren Harding, James Buchanan, and Andrew Jackson didn't father any, let's look at Vance's twisted logic.  The statement was first made in 2021, when he was running for the Senate.  In it, he said to Tucker Carlson, 

"We're effectively run in this country . . . by a bunch of childless cat ladies who are miserable at their own lives and the choices that they've made, and so they want to make the rest of the country miserable, too. You look at Kamala Harris, Pete Buttigieg, AOC, the entire future of the Democrats is controlled by people without children. And how does it make any sense that we've turned our country over to people who don't really have a direct stake in it."

The majority of the backlash over this statement has focused on the "cat lady" part, leading to some pretty fabulous memes.  A number of women from both sides of the aisle have taken to social media to point out that not all women are childless by choice and that being childless doesn't necessarily make you miserable.  Adoptive parents and step parents have made the case that they love their kids just as much as anyone who has given birth to theirs.  Vance claims to have been misquoted by the left, but given the fact that what is being shared is video of the Fox interview, that seems farfetched at best.  

Supporters of Vance have doubled down on the part about not having a direct stake in the future.  Since some of them have said it directly to me, a childless woman (who also happens to have one cat), that's the part I would like to address.    

My call to singleness was unexpected.  I very much wanted to be a wife and mother and assumed throughout my twenties that it would happen one day.  But God had other plans for me.  When He led me in this direction, I did not become miserable in my own life. I thought, "Well, that's good to know.  I can start making plans around that."  I bought a house because I no longer felt the need to wait until I was sharing a mortgage.  I did not go get a bunch of cats because I had one and it didn't occur to me to think my now permanent single state required more than that.  

Most importantly to this discussion, I didn't quit my teaching career.  I dove deeper into it than ever, knowing that the way God would use me to touch the future was through other people's kids.  I sponsored clubs, continued to grow in my role as yearbook advisor, read more about cognitive science, and volunteered to chaperone most things.  In my 25 year career, I have taught nearly 3000 students. I have taught entire families, one sibling after another.  Many of my students have kids of their own, and I have had secondary impact on them. My "direct stake in the future" wasn't expressed through a small number of kids in my home but through a large number of kids in my classroom.

You might be thinking, "Okay, but you are just one weirdo. Most people who have no children don't think the way you do."  Agreed.  I'm strange, but let me give a few examples of other strange and childless people whose impact on the future we are still benefitting from.  
  • Shall we start with the obvious?  Jesus Christ himself had no children.  Okay, that's cheating, I know.  I get that's a little different because He was Divine.  How about the apostle Paul?  He not only viewed Timothy as a non-biological son, but he certainly cared deeply about the future.  Far from the JD Vance perspective, he thought being single and childless gave him more of a stake in God's mission and advocated that others be like he was in order to fulfill God's purposes.
  • Isaac Newton certainly had an impact on the future, given that we still teach his work over 400 years after his death.  He never married or fathered a child.  Vance might have considered him week or miserable, but without him, we would have little understanding of physics today.
  • Artists like DaVinci and Michelangelo considered their works of art to be their children, and those works are still inspiring people today.  If they had children, would we have The David, The Pieta, or The Last Supper?  Maybe.  But also, maybe not.  God had a different purpose for them than he does for many.
  • CS Lewis was well into middle age when he met his wife, Joy.  He raised her sons after her death, but JD Vance would say that doesn't count (at least that seems to be how feels about Kamala's step children).  Yet, even before he met her, he was the author of many children's stories, science fiction, and theological masterpieces. He very much understood his stake in the future.
  • If you have ever been through a natural disaster, had a home fire, or needed blood, you have benefitted from the American Red Cross.  It was founded by Clara Barton.  She had no children, but she clearly felt some "direct stake in the future" and had a direct impact on it.
  • Women like me only have the right to vote in elections like the one in which JD Vance is running because of women like Susan B. Anthony, who wanted voting rights, not only for herself, but for women in the future, in spite of not having given birth to children.
  • More recently, theologian John Stott chose singleness.  While he recognized that it was "no higher or holier vocation than marriage," he also said, "If marriage is good, singleness is also good. It's an example of the balance of Scripture."  For a full interview with him on this topic, click here.
  • Dolly Parton and her husband never had any children, yet she has done more for children's literacy than anyone since Barbara Bush.  Why would she care if children read?  Because, she doesn't have the short sighted view that she will only care about that which directly affects her.
  • And, of course, there are countless nuns and monks and priests who have forgone marriage and children to focus on the future.
  • There is one that JD Vance doesn't seem to mind (or at least hasn't mentioned publicly).  Lindsey Graham has never been married or had children.  I would assume that his two decades plus in the Senate means he believes he has some stake in the future.  One would think he might speak out about the Vance statements, but he sold out to Trump world some time ago; so I wouldn't hold my breath.

Why is this hard for so many to understand?  Because we focus on our own experience, and 90% of adults have the experience of having children.  I focused on my experience earlier, and so has everyone in this conversation online. Those who are parents describe their experience of having a different view of the future after they had children.  I have no doubt that is true.  In every conversation I have ever had on this topic (and there were many prior to this week), I have acknowledged that people with children of their own have a perspective I do not have; so I get that.  Those who have suffered infertility and miscarriages have talked about how that experience changed them, and that is certainly true as well because their view of the future as it pertains to their children is eternity rather than a few decades.  Those who have adopted, fostered, or in some way raised the children of someone else have shared their experience, discussing how different it is to have choice rather than biology deepen their love for their children, and I have no problem recognizing the beauty of that.  

The world is made up of more than one perspective, and that is what JD Vance doesn't understand.  He believes his experience should be the universal experience because he cannot conceive of people who managed to have a view of the future that involves their legacy rather than their progeny.  

You may wonder where the overlap is with education.  Many of your kids teachers are people who have not had children.  Some want kids and just haven't had them yet, especially if they are younger.  Some, like me, have found other people's children to be their calling.  Whatever your interaction with these teachers is, please don't assume that they don't understand children just because they don't have them at home.  It's easy to do and it seems to win arguments, but it hurts them deeply, whether it comes from parents, colleagues, or supervisors.  

I was once in a faculty meeting where the discussion was about homework.  The head of school I had at the time looked at us and said, "If you aren't a parent, you'll NEVER understand."  I put the emphasis on never because he did.  That word was like a dagger in the middle of the sentence.  I had only recently recognized my call to singleness and was accepting that, by not having family concerns, I could focus on becoming the best teacher I could be.  I tried to explain it to him (that was before I realized he was a person who doubled down on things rather than moderate them).  I told him it was like he was saying, "Oh, that call of God on your life?  Yeah, you can't be good at that either."  But, it fell on deaf ears, and there were definitely more statements like it in future meetings.  While that statement felt like he found the soft part of my heart and jabbed it with a sharp stick, my pain was small compared to that of the two teachers weeping in the row behind me.  One was a man dealing with his wife's infertility and had just begun the adoption process.  The other was a woman who had experienced a miscarriage just three weeks before this meeting.  My point is not that you don't have a different perspective if you have had a kid crying about homework at the kitchen table; my point is that you don't know what someone else's experience is when you say things like, "you'll NEVER understand."  So be careful with that.

I got it from colleagues and parents throughout my twenties and early thirties.  It seemed to settle after I turned thirty-seven.  I think some people didn't assume I was single and childless at that point, and I also think my reputation did me a lot of favors because I had been at the same school for so long that people better understood my heart for their kids.  But, it shouldn't take that long, and the teacher shouldn't have to prove their love of kids to you after choosing a career in education when they could have worked fewer hours for more pay in another field.  If your child is in the classroom of a teacher who doesn't have children of his or her own, be grateful for the kind of time that teacher has to devote to your child.  Don't use it against them just because it is a card you can throw down when you disagree about a policy.  

Every living human has a "direct stake in the future" because we are all part of mankind.  JD Vance and his apologists don't understand the basic concept of how interconnected all humans are, so I'd like to end with the words of someone who did.  John Donne wrote these words about being "involved in mankind" in 1624.  Maybe JD Vance will like them since Donne fathered 12 children and, as far as I know, didn't have any cats, making him worth listening to.  



Sunday, July 21, 2024

Data - Can You Have Too Much of a Good Thing?

When I was growing up, I had an excellent pastor.  He was deeply insightful, and he handled the preaching of God's Word with intelligence.  He showed me what it meant to love God with all my mind.  There was one area of his life, however, where he did not apply the same level of intellect - his eating habits.  He loved snacks, but he was also very concerned about his appearance.  So he weighed himself - a lot.  He weight himself before he consumed anything and decided what to eat based on that number, resulting in unusual things, like eating half an Oreo and three peanuts for lunch.  This, friends, is the weird result of too much access to data.

You may be wondering what I am going on about in a blog that is meant to be about education.  Well, anyone who has been around education in the past 5 years or so knows that we have become obsessed with data.  Some schools even proudly market themselves with the term "data driven." We analyze every standardized test score (in spite of research showing they are not predictive of success), monitor GPAs, and act reactively to the slightest deviations in the bell curve.  Some parents hover over the school's digital reports of every grade, big or small, and contact the teacher over every lost point.  Much like my pastor's strange food decisions that no dietician would ever support, our obsession with academic data leads to strange educational decisions that are not based on good pedagogy.

I'm not saying we swing the pendulum back too far the other direction.  There was a time when we had almost no access to data.  Students and parents found out what the grade was when report cards came out.  At that point, it was too late to adjust course in any way.  That is too little access to data.  Neither of these extremes is helpful to the education or flourishing of students.  So, what is the sweet spot?

Let me try to make a comparison outside of the academia.  As you all know, I take and teach indoor cycle classes at the YMCA.  A few months after I started taking cycle classes, I began setting goals about distance, tension level, and power on the bike.  At first, I only knew how to check these statistics at the end of a class. I was often surprised to get to the end of a workout and find that I hadn’t achieved as much distance as I had thought or that my average speed was lower than I had mentally calculated.  Because I wasn’t tracking that information at all during the class, I didn’t have the ability to make adjustments that would help me reach my goals.  This is the workout equivalent of our world prior to digital grade access. I could do better on a different day, but I didn’t know how to do better in real time. 

Then, an instructor showed me how to use the bike’s computer to see real time information during class by changing the display screens.  It was tempting to stay on the screen with the information I cared most about.  After all, feedback is good, right?  I quickly learned that was unwise.  It made me so focused on the number that I couldn’t pay attention to instructions.  Worse, I was so focused on the number that I couldn’t enjoy doing the things that would improve the number, and I was in a state of stress if the average didn’t move as quickly as I thought it should.  Worst of all, I wasn’t building any internal sense of how to improve because I was relying too much on the bike itself rather than how my legs felt or how hard I was working.  This is the equivalent of reacting to every homework and quiz grade in real time. Students aren't able to enjoy learning or focus on how to learn well because they are too focused on each and every point.

Eventually, in those cycle classes, I learned to discipline myself to only visit that screen once every four minutes.  That gave me enough information to figure out what I need to do to make progress for the next four minute check, but it didn’t do my thinking for me. I could see if I was building an internal sense of how I was doing by making a mental prediction of where I would be before going to check the number. I could enjoy the music and the instructor because I wasn't staring constantly at the numbers on the screen. Teachers and parents should keep in mind that a grade is an average for a reason.  This will prevent us from overreacting to every task score.  Parents who check the average with every entry cause themselves a lot of unnecessary stress and raise the anxiety level of their children.  Perhaps, parents and students could make checking the LMS part of a weekly routine, checking it on Fridays in order to make a plan for the following week. Perhaps that's the sweet spot between too much data and no data at all.

Let's recognize that, like most complex endeavors, education is multifaceted. It has layers of purposes and goals, and there are many aspects of schooling that don't show up in data reports.  Grade data is ONE facet, but it doesn't tell the whole story. Standardized tests exist for a reason, but we go too far when we assume they show anything other than a snapshot of learning.  Evaluating a school on standardized test scores ALONE would be equivalent to judging a movie based solely on the poster.  Just because data is easy to check doesn't mean we should think it shows us everything we need to know.  Data doesn't include classroom climate, student attitudes toward learning, growth across time, use of resources, support of struggling learners, or how alumni prosper as a result of our having taught them.  

Water is a good thing, but when there is too much of it, you can drown.  

Data's a good thing, but let's not drown ourselves in too much of it.

  


Sunday, July 7, 2024

Enlist Help

For the past month, I have been working the front desk at my local branch of the YMCA.  There is a lot to learn - and I mean a lot.  From the basic functions of the computer system in making scan cards, charging people for personal training, and selling guest passes, there are rules about who is allowed to receive a seven day pass and when people can leave their children at the drop in child care.  There is simply no way to train in all of it at once, so I spend a fair amount of time doing things incorrectly.  One of my co-workers, Helena, is often the one left to tell me, and she always feels bad about it.  I keep telling her that she shouldn't feel bad and that I would much rather have a kind and well-meaning person tell me I'm doing something wrong than to keep doing it wrong.  Obviously, what I would much rather were happening is that I would be doing things right, but there is too much to learn for that to be happening yet.

We are around a month away from teachers returning to school for the inservice days before school starts.  New teachers, it is an exciting time for you, but it is also daunting.  Don't let that scare you.  There is a lot to learn. There are going to be many things you weren't taught in teacher school that will become part of your daily life.  For a while, you are going to stumble into scenarios you don't know how to handle, requests from parents that you aren't sure are reasonable, and student situations you won't know how to navigate.  My best advice is not to try to do it on your own.  Enlist help from the wisest person you can find.  That might be the mentor teacher your school assigns you, but that also might not be your most natural relationship.  If you organically develop a relationship with teacher next door or across the hall, it might be them.  It might be the principal or the librarian.  Admit your vulnerability, and seek wisdom.  It is simply not possible for you to know all the nuances of student, parent, colleague interactions in addition to your content and your pedagogy.

I've had a number of those people over the years.  In my first school, it was, in fact my assigned mentor, but that doesn't always happen.  I also had a great principal who had a story for everything, teaching me that mistakes weren't fatal.  At GRACE, I had a few over the years.  My art teacher friend, Elizabeth, was a great listening ear and wise when it came to student interactions.  The teachers surrounding my room (Zane, Melanie, Meagan, Alyssa) were often the ones I asked to look at email replies before I hit send.  My English teacher friend, Kellie, was the person I went to if I needed someone to disagree with me in order to evaluate my own position.  My history teacher friend, Amy, provided good perspective on spiritual issues.  Our librarian/media specialist, Marcia, was the person I bounced new ideas off of.  

Whether you a new teacher or an experienced one, teaching is a complex endeavor, and you never stop needing help.  In my 25th year, I was giving advice some days while still asking for advice on other days.  Keep learning.  Keep asking questions.  Keep enlisting help.  

Sunday, June 30, 2024

Can vs. Should

This is America.  In spite of the assertions of some extreme right and left people, that means we are free to do a lot of things (I guess those people want to be free to do anything, but that's not how society works).  But just because we can do some things doesn't mean we should.  There should be something inside you that prevents you from doing and/or saying certain things.  That inhibiting factor might be religious regulations, ethnic culture, or how your parents raised you.  But if there is nothing in your heart that makes you pause and ask "Should I do this?" rather than "Can I do it?" it is not a sign that you were more free, just less ethical.

I'll give you an example.  In 2020, during the time of the public's reaction to the killing of George Floyd by a Minneapolis police officer, most of the protests were peaceful, but there were some that wrongly turned to violent riots involving property damage and danger to human life.  There is much to be discussed and analyzed in the response of many during this time, but what I found disheartening was that some of the people I love responded with glee that they could turn their attention to the riots, distracting themselves from the need to respond to the racism that sparked it all.  A friend of mine posted a meme with a very famous photograph of the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor with the caption, "Democrats would call this a mostly peaceful day in Hawaii." I responded that I thought it was wrong to use this photo as a joke. Her first response was to explain it to me as though I didn't get it and then to tell me she had free speech as an American.  The first amendment does protect her from legal backlash, but it shouldn't prevent her from personal reflection.  There should have been something inside of her that said, "Maybe it isn't a great idea to use a powerful photograph from a horrific event in which American servicemen died to mock people."  Just because you can doesn't mean you should.  Another friend shared clearly doctored photographs to mock people with whom he disagreed.  When people pointed out that the photos were obviously not real, he responded in angry ways that he was allowed to post whatever he wanted (true) and it was funny, so they should get over it.  So, in his mind, spreading lies is fine as long he gets to mock someone he hates. I've had the same disheartening feelings this week as I've watched fellow Christians gleefully mock Joe Biden's age after his dismal debate performance.  Christian friends, remind yourself that one of the fruits of the Spirit is self control.  We could be having a serious discussion about the merits of these two men and the policies each would have and the impact those policies would have on the world, but instead, we've chosen a less humane route simply because it is more entertaining. Can you do it?  Obviously yes.  Should you?  Obviously no.

Examples of this concept abound.  I am generally a capitalist because I do believe that market competition usually leads to better products (not always, things are more complicated than that).  I also know that we are people with sin natures and anyone, left completely unchecked, will have temptations to do wrong.   A lot of people will justify immoral practices if they are not explicitly against the rules.  Therefore, some reasonable regulations are necessary.  In a great example of self restraint, author Vern Poythress applies his morals over socially acceptable rules.  He could make a lot more money than he does, but he has decided to forgo copyright on his own work by making it freely available online. He believes knowledge should be free to all.  Something in him compels him to choose, not just what he could do, but what he believes is the right thing to do.

There's no way to write this post without quoting one of the greatest characters ever put on screen.  Dr. Ian Malcolm, the chaos theorist portrayed by Jeff Goldblum in Jurrasic Park, warned park creator John Hammond about the end results of recreating extinct predators, saying, "your scientists were so preoccupied with whether or not they could, they didn't stop to think if they should.”  We're seeing this all over as technology advances at an unprecedented rate.  We worship  convenience on the altar of entertainment, so we have loaded app after app on our phones without pausing to reflect on whether they are good for us.  When we finally recognize the negative impact, the devices are already too ingrained in society to undo it.  In a move even George Orwell didn't predict, we have voluntarily brought devices into our homes that listen to us at all times.  Should we?  We never bother to ask ourselves.  It's more convenient, so we don't care.  

We are doing the same thing with the rapid expansion of AI.  Science fiction writers have spent decades warning us about the potential impact of allowing machines to learn and think for themselves.  Rather than heed those warnings, we are saying, "I can do something a little faster than before?  Yep. Let's move forward with it as quickly as possible."  I'm not just talking about students using it to cheat (which they absolutely will - some of the AI apps are marketing themselves as "never get caught.").  I'm not just talking about adults using it to get out of the hard work of thinking for themselves (Be careful.  AI flat out makes things up that don't exist, and you won't know if you aren't prepared to do the work to find out.). I'm talking about art forgery, deep fake videos, and inaccurate patient care.  These things are already happening.  AI is going to make us all a little less human, and it is going to make some of us a lot less human.  One day, we will look around and wonder how we got here.  But every time I say this, the response is, "Well, it's not going anywhere, so we have to accept reality."  Do we?  Can't we take some control over our own lives?  It doesn't have to be this way, but we care more about convenience than reflection.  I'm not saying we should not progress technologically; I'm saying it is worth slowing down to ask some questions before we proceed without limits.  Sadly, I don't see that happening.

You can't control what is available, but you can control what you adopt in your own life.  I resisted owning a cell phone until I was 47 and a half years old.  I wouldn't have one now if I hadn't been changing jobs.  I am, however, limiting my use of it.  I refuse to install social media apps or games onto it because I've seen what that does to people.  I use it for my job, and I text and make calls, but I will not make it a source of entertainment or use it to pay for things.  Your line and mine don't have to be the same, but you should take some times to figure out what your values are rather than using everything just because you can.

Sunday, June 23, 2024

Measurable Growth

Yesterday, I had an "off day" in my indoor cycling class.  It happens occasionally.  I just can't get my legs to go as fast as the instructor is cuing or push through a level that it could do earlier in the week.  Last Wednesday, I had a similar problem in my weightlifting class.  A weight that I have been putting on my back for several months using a clean and press simply refused to be lifted.  Even when I dropped down a bit, I tapped my forehead with the bar on my first attempt to pull it up and had to sit out a few reps during the set.  There are a lot of reasons for this.  Sometimes, I haven't eaten enough before going to class.  Other times I've been getting a cold that hasn't yet exhibited symptoms.  There have been times where I just haven't recovered from the previous day's class, and my legs, arms, shoulders, or core don't have more to give.  It can be discouraging if you are only comparing today to yesterday or this week to last week.  But, yesterday when I looked at my "off day" performance, I realized that a year ago, this would have been a very good day.  I was averaging just over a mile in four minutes.  That's lower than my current level of normal, but a year ago, it was my goal time for a mile, and four months before that, I hadn't even started cycling yet.  That weight I couldn't lift over my head last Wednesday was over 20 pounds heavier than what I was doing the same moves with a year ago.  In other words, I have made progress; and I know that because I have measurements.  

Recently, Adam Boxer posted this question on Twitter.  There were fifty replies directly to him and dozens more in conversations with the repliers, and it led to some interesting discussions.  My answer was that there wasn't enough information to tell, but that was largely because I don't understand the British system and how the curriculum is tested.  I would imagine a student or parent would look at this list and say they have regressed, but that is also a misrepresentation of the question.  After a few days of discussion, Adam gave his answer.  Each score showed that they had learned some of the content on that exam, almost none of which they had known before.  Therefore, the student had, in fact made progress.  I would also pose that (again, I don't know their system, so I could be wrong) the material probably increases in complexity and difficulty level as the year goes on, so having achieved competency on 40% of that content may be equal to or even better than knowing 80% of the material presented earlier in the year (more comparable to my "off day"after having progressed to a higher level).  

My point is this.  Growth is measurable.  Whether it is how much weight I can lift on an average day or the height of a plant, reading fluency, or how much a student has learned about math, there are ways to track it and observe progress.  It is not, however, always easy to measure.  In a different thread discussion on Twitter, a number of people replied to Greg Ashman's assertion about explicit and instruction and things that are measurable with some version of "really important parts of education are not measurable." I understand their point. Teachers teach a lot more than academic content, things like kindness, respect, teamwork, etc.  I would posit that a researcher running an experiment would be able to find a way to measure those things (How many times did a child smile at a classmate?  How often were kind words spoken?), and they would have people posted who jobs were to count those things.  But, the average teacher obviously cannot do that.  We have to base it more on general observations and "vibe," but that doesn't make growth in those areas immeasurable.  Growth can always be seen.

Grades are a piece of data, and I am not one of the people who think they should be abolished (I'm all for modifications to the way they are assigned, but one of the things pandemic lockdowns taught us was that students would not keep learning for intrinsic reasons if we got rid of them, as had been previously asserted).  I do think it is valuable to keep them in perspective.  Grades are A PIECE of data, but they are just one piece.  There are many formative assessments, checks for understanding, discussions with students about their learning, written work, and projects/labs which we put together in our understanding of student growth.  Teachers don't have time to consolidate those in a formal way, but over time, we grow our professional judgment to the point where we are able to develop a reasonable idea of growth from all of those inputs.  Grades matter; they just aren't the only things that matter.

It's summer, so none of this is helpful yet.  But when the school year begins next year, take in where your kids are.  You are taking in a constant stream of input.  You might be in a class where formal pretests are given, or you might just do some informal surveying of your class's knowledge.  You might even make it into a game that gives you actual information rather than icebreakers that 0.0% of people enjoy playing.  As the year goes on, you might repeat those questions (perhaps on one of those days that has a lot of interruptions where you have a hard time making forward progress).  This will give you a measurable way to track progress in your students.  Be sure to celebrate that growth with them, so when they have "an off day," they can recognize that they have grown to the point where what used to be out of their reach is now their norm.

Sunday, June 16, 2024

Adapting When the Plan is Interrupted - Focus on the Goal

Friday, I was psyched about the playlist I was going to use as I subbed for Jay's indoor cycle class.  It was as close as I would be subbing to Juneteenth, so I had constructed the class around Stevie Wonder, Aretha Franklin, Ray Charles, Tina Turner, Otis Redding, Della Reese, Jon Batiste, Fantasia Barrino, even Della Reese and Bobby McFerrin.  I always play some music at a low level while people are arriving, but I didn't know until a few minutes before the start of class that I couldn't make the volume go any higher.  (Coincidentally, one of the pieces of feedback I got after last week's observation was that I should make the music louder, and here I was unable to do so.). I tried a few trouble shooting ideas, but none of them worked.  I attempted to change to a portable speaker, but I didn't have the right cord to connect with my iPod (yes, I still use one).  I started class and apologized for how quiet it would be.  One of the directors came in a few minutes later to attempt to fix the system, but she couldn't make it work either.  A person entered with a cord for the portable player.  It did make it louder, but there was some kind of glitch in it that wouldn't allow it to play the vocal track.  I kept going with the class while attempting to make things better with the music.  Thankfully, the members of the class were very patient, and we all got a good workout (but I was bummed that my great playlist wasn't be heard - I'll definitely use it another time).  

Throughout the class, I remembered several of the questions Julie had asked me when she interviewed me for the job. "What experience do you have with adapting to things when they don't go according to plan?  How do you adapt?"  As with most questions, my teaching experience had a lot to inform the answer.  Things interrupt the plan all the time in the classroom.  It turns out that students don't have the prerequisite knowledge they need to understand today's lesson.  The fire alarm goes off while you are in the middle of a critical problem, or worse, mid-lab experiment.  A spider crawls across someone's desk (if you aren't an educator, trust me, this VERY much interferes with whatever plan you have for the day).  My answer to Julie when she asked was that I stayed focused on the goal, not the method for achieving it.  That's definitely what I had to do on Friday, but it was not the first time, and I'm sure it won't be the last.  

Students need to see that the goal is what matters.  It's okay to get a little flummoxed while you figure out how to shift gears when the video won't play or internet is down when you had a great digital activity planned, but you shouldn't spend the whole period on it.  You should ask yourself what the learning goal of that experience was.  Can you accomplish it through direct instruction even if you didn't plan to?  Can you teach tomorrow's lesson today and hope the internet will be back in strength tomorrow?  Can students work on a project today so you have time to try to make the video work for tomorrow?  Moving the learning forward is the main goal, not the ideal order or method you had planned.  

In addition to students seeing that the goal matters, they will see that setbacks don't have to be fatal.  In his new book, Uprise, Kevin Washburn talks about having A and B goals.  The A goal is what you want to achieve if everything goes as planned, but the B goal should be your definition of success if conditions are not ideal.  If you model this for students, they will benefit on something larger than the academic level.  They will see resilience, a characteristic they will very much need "in real life," as they say.  And people do notice.  Young or old, students notice the teacher's response to things.  On Friday, one of the senior gentlemen in the room came up to me afterward and said he liked that I maintained a good attitude and wanted to know when I would be teaching again.  Teenagers will notice too.  

Learning and the Brain - Austin - Raw Notes for Saturday

Note: These are raw notes, taken in real time during the presentation. They have not been edited. I also have a tendency to add my own thoug...